HomeMy WebLinkAbout2024/04/15 - ADMIN - Minutes - City Council - Study SessionIf St.Louis ParkJIrsesor»Official m inutes
Local board of appeal &equalization
St.Louis Park,M innesota
April 15,2024
1.Reconvene the St.Louis Park Local Board of Appeal and Equalization
The St.Louis Park Local Bo ard of A ppeal and Equalizatio n w as reco nvened at 5:30 p.m .
2.Roll call -Declaration of quorum .
Bo ard m e m b e rs present:Pau l Baudhuin,Tim Brausen,Sue Budd,Lynette Dum alag,Yolanda
Farris,M argaret Ro g,N ad ia M o ham ed (arrived at 5:35 p.m .)
Bo ard m e m b e rs ab sent:no ne
Staff present:city m an ager (M s.Keller),city assesso r (M r.Bultem a),ap praiser Ill (M s.
N athanso n),ap p raise r I (M r.Oelrich),fi nance directo r (M s.Cruver)
G u e sts:Jo shu a Ho og land ,He nnepin County assesso r
3.Acknow ledgement of trained m embers (Budd and M oham ed)
The Bo ard ackno w le dg ed m e m b ers Budd and M o ham ed as their trained m em b ers.
4.Review of propert ies in appeal.
a.Board action -A pp ellant &assessing staff are not in agreem ent-there w ere no
ap p eals m e etin g this criterio n.
b.Board action -A pp ellant has requ ested referral to the co unty bo ard -there w ere tw o
ap p eals that m et this criterio n.M r.Bultem a read the cases into the record:
-70 0 0 Lake Street W est,PID #171172144039 valuatio n of record at $680,000 and
sustain w as requ ested as staff has not been ab le to arrange inspectio n.
Boa rd M em b er Bra usen m ade a m o tion,seco nded by Board M em ber D um alag to
sustain.
The m o tion passed 6-0 (Board M em ber M oham ed absent).
-57 20 Excelsio r Blvd,PID #211 1721240040 valuatio n of reco rd at $858,000 and
sustain w as req u ested as staff has not been ab le to arrange inspectio n.
Bo ard M em b er Bra usen m ade a m o tion,second ed by Board M em ber Farris,to sustain.
The m o tion p assed 6-0 (Board M em ber M oham ed absent).
Local board of appeal and equalization -2-April 15,2024
c.Board action -Appellant has refused inspection,w ithdraw n or not responded -there
w ere five appeals that m et this criterion.M r.Bultema read the cases into the record:
3986 W ooddale Ave.,#201,PID#0702824230178,valuation of record $526,900,
reco m m endation to sustain.
Board M em b er D um a /ag m ade a m o tion,second ed by Board M em b er Bra usen,to sustain.
The m o tion p assed 6-0 (Board M em ber M oham ed absent).
3980 W ooddale Ave,#302,PID#0702824230187,valuation of record $507,000,
reco m m endation to sustain.
Boa rd M em b er Bra usen m ade a m otion,seco nd ed by Board M em ber D um alag,to sustain.
The m o tion p assed 6-0 (Board M em ber M oham ed absent).
3970 W ooddale Ave.,#10 1,PID#0702824230213 ,valuation of record $553,300,
recom m ended to sustain.
Board M em b er Ba u d uin m a de a m o tion,seco nd ed by Board M em ber Rog,to sustain.
The m o tion p assed 6-0 (Board M em ber M oham ed absent).
3970 W ood dale Ave.,#202,PID#0702824230216,valuation of record $505,900,
recom m ended to sustain.
Bo ard M em b er Bra usen m ad e a m o tion,seco nd ed by Board M em ber Farris,to sustain.
The m o tion passed 6-0 (Board M em ber M oham ed absent).
4327 Bro ok Lane.,PID#211 17213 40077,valuation of record $832,700 reco m m ended
to sustain.
Board M em b er Rog m ad e a m otion,seco nd ed by Board M em b er Bra usen,to sustain.
The m o tion p assed 6-0 (Board M em ber M oham ed absent).
d.Board action -Appellant &assessing staff are in m utual agreem ent as to the value
change.No classifications w ere appealed.Mr.Oelrich read each parcel into the record.
The pro p erties as read into the record are attached to these m inutes as an addend um .
Bo ard m em b er Bra usen m ad e a m o tion,second ed by Farris,to accept the m utually agreed
up on valuations as presented by staff.
The m o tion passed 7-0.
Local board of appeal and equalization -3-April 15,2024
5.Instruct assessor to complete record of changes fo r submitt al.
Board chair Bud d instructed the assessor to com plete the record of changes fo r subm itt al.
6.Instruct assessor to info rm petitioners of board action via mail.
Bo ard chair Bud d instructed the assessor to info rm petitioners of board action via m ail.
7.Com plete the Local Board of Appeal and Equalization Certification Form .
Board chair Budd verified that the Local Board of A ppeal and Equalization Certification
w as co m p leted.The reco rd fo rm is incl uded as an att achm ent to these m inutes.
8.Adjourn if board business is com pleted.
The m eeting adjo urn ed at 5:44 p.m .-==Sue Budd,chair,lo cal board of app eal
an d equalizatio n
Oe0Co
D
O...0r
3
(')
Ro ster -City of St.Lo u is Park lo cal Bo ard of A pp eal &Eq u alization -Reconvene A pril 15,2024
I 2024 Appealed Assessing Owner/Rep Board I
Classification 2024 Value Revaluation Indicated Action
-~-Holiday Station Stores,Inc.via Representative 7000 Lake St W 17 11 7-21 -44-0039 $651,000 C-Commercial $680,000 Inspect /Sustain Respond?/CB AE
Holiday Station Stores,Inc.via Representative 5720 Excelsior Blvd 21-11 7-21 -24-0040 $821 ,000 C Commercial $858,000 Inspect/Sustain Respond?/CB AE
Jessica Drapacho 3986 w ooddale Ave 2 01 07 028-24-23-0178 $469,300 X-Condominium $526,900 Sustain W ithdraw
Susan Book 3980 W ooddale Ave #302 07-028-24-23-0187 $451,600 X-Condominium $507,000 Sustain W ithdraw
Patricia Bosacker 3970 W ooddale Ave #101 070 28-24-23 0 213 $492,800 x-Condominium $553,300 Sustain W ithdraw
Chad &Beth Babco ck 3970 W ooddale Ave #202 07-028-24-23-0216 $450,600 X-Condominium $505,900 Sustain W ithdraw
Lauren Schrock 4327 Bro ok La 21-117-21-34 -0077 $819,900 R-Residential $832,700 Sustain W ithdraw
Em m a DeRubeis 1829 Idaho Ave S 05-11 7-21-43-0022 $371 ,900 R-Residential $374,100 $333,700 Mutually Agreed
Jessica Erickson &Sergio Sarm iento Ortega 3532 Glenhurst Ave 06-028-24-41-0039 $506,100 R-Residential $509,700 $450,000 Mutually Agreed
Elizabeth Rochon 3980 W ooddale Ave #101 07-028-24-23-0182 $561,700 X-Condominium $630,600 $560,000 Mutually Agreed
Jennifer Schaidler 3980 W ooddale Ave #102 07-028-24-23 -0183 $633,400 X-Condominium $711 ,200 $576,000 Mutually Agreed
O Anna-Lisa Erickson 396 2 W ooddale Ave #302 07-028-24-23.0230 $490,500 X-Condominium $550,700 $532,000 Mutually Agreed
e Sulan Yen &Daniel Nichols 4370 Dart Ave S 07-028-24-34-0034 $850,300 R-Residential $874,800 $860,000 Mutually Agreed0cTimothyLarocque910824thStW07-11 7-21-24-0015 $384,400 R-Residential $398,000 $350,000 Mutually AgreedO
O Evan Rousseau 7006 24th St W 08-11 7-21-13 -0074 $431,800 R-Residential $420,400 $404,100 Mutually Agreed
Logan Kinsel 3031 Rhode Island Ave S 17-11 7-21-22 -0044 $423,400 R-Residential $462,400 $400,000 Mutually Agreed
Scott Snyder 3310 Aquila La 18-11 7-21-24-0027 $568,700 R-Residential $615,500 $445,000 Mutually Agreed
Thom as M elcher 3930 Alabam a Ave S 21-117-21-23-010 2 $454,000 R-Residential $462,900 $415,000 Mutually Agreed
Nina Flats,LLC via ow ner Geoff M arkham 6211 Ham ilton St 16-11 7-21-32-0090 $921 ,000 A-Apartment $921,000 $880,000 Mutually Agreed
Kun LI RE LLC-Ell a Li 6200 Excelsior Blvd #103 21-11 7-21 -32-013 5 $155,300 C-Commercial $160,400 $13 5,000 Mutually Agreed
mlLJC:.t"Al"'CIMt.NI
OF REVENUE
Local Board of Appeal and Equalization Certification Form for 2024
The Local Board of Appeal and Equalization (LBAE)must complete and sign this form for each meeting of the local board.Since all local boards
are required to comply with the training and quorum requirements,this form must be completed even if no appeals are heard.At the end of each
LBAE meeting,the county assessor or authorized city assessor takes possession of the completed form.
Section 1 -Complete the following information at the beginning of the meeting.
County name !Jurisdiction name (indicate city or town)
Hennepin ~St Louis Park
Meeting (circle one):firs)!Date
!
Time la.mconvenedMonday,April 15,2024 5:30 l.m
~Township/City Board Members
•List all voting members of the LBAE and check "Present''or "Absent''for each one to indicate which members were in attendance.
•For each voting member present,check "Yes"or "No"indicating if the member has completed the training required under Minnesota Statutes,Section
274.014 within the last four years.All voting members present at the meeting must sign this form.By signing this form,you certify that you attended
the LBAE meeting.
•You are also certifying that no board member participated in actions concerning the valuation or classification of a property owned by the board member,
the board member's spouse,parent,stepparent,child,stepchild,grandparent,grandchild,brother,sister,uncle aunt,nephew,or niece of a board
member,or any property in which the board member has a financial interest (the relationships may be by blood or marriage).
Print names of all voting members Title Attendance Training certified Signature (for those in attendance only)
Yolanda Farris Board Member [3resent []Absent Jes 0o x db0,/J
Lynnette Dumalag Board Member [Sresent []Absent Jes Go X U l..-i /
Margaret Rog Board Member [(Present [Absent Ives Go x "l of
Sue Budd Board Chair [5[resent []Absent ]Yes Jo Xi,,=~"-s '
Tim Brausen Board Member f]Present [Absent [Jes Jo X !\y ,SC/O
Paul Baudhuin Board Member Seresent [JAb»sent,]Yves No x J.?-~
Nadia Mohamed Board Member Present []Absent Yes JNo X 'h ~"'.!,Auf.TEI
Assessment Personnel
Must be completed by the county assessor (or an assistant delegated by the county assessor)or authorized city assessor present at the meeting.
Local assessor information County assessor (or delegate)/authorized city assessor information
Does this jurisdiction have a local assessor?}Yes Jo Name
I
Title lilicense no.
lf yes,was the local assessor present?[]Yes No Josh Hoogland County Assessor 3165
Local assessor name lllicense no.County assessor (or delegate)/authorized city assessor certification
Cory Bultema 2530
[
igning below,I certify I was present at the meeting and (please check one):
A quorum was present and a training certified member was present;or
Other assessment personnel present I took over the meeting and changed it to an open book format because:
Please list additional names on back of this form.B A quorum was not present,and/or
A trained member was not present.
Name Title County assessor (or delegate)/authori;d city_assessor signature
Bridget Nathanson Appraiser Ill ---✓1·~Name Title X -a_
Jethro Oelrich Appraiser I 86ard 6ber acknowledgeloss of LBAE for this and following assessment
Name /e»year {due to reason checked above).
X
I Section2 -Complete the following information at the end of the meeting.!
Meeting (circle one):eseas or a/me/we 544 l□a.m
5.m-Scheduling for Reconvene Meeting (if needed)
The LBAE must resolve all issues before the meeting is adjourned.If issues are unresolved,the board should recess until the next meeting.The
LBAE must complete and sign a LBAE Certification Form for each reconvene meeting The date and time for the reconvene meeting must be
determined before the initial meeting is recessed.Once the LBAE has adjourned it cannot reconvene.
Date for reconvene meeting !Time [Jam
[Jo.m
DO,104