HomeMy WebLinkAbout1969/10/27 - ADMIN - Minutes - City Council - Regular MINUTES OF SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
ST . LOUIS PARK , MINNESOTA
October 27 , 1969
A special meeting of the City Council was called to order by Mayor Thiel at
8 : 20 p . m .
The following Councilmen were present :
Murray Galinson
Richard Graves
James Heltzer
Frank Howard
Richard Koch
Robert Reynolds
Leonard Thiel
Also present were the City Manager , Assistant City Manager , City Attorney ,
City Clerk , Police Chief , Police Captain , Detective Morgan , Officer Beltrand
and Acting Secretary ,
Councilman Galinson moved to appoint Richard Schrad as acting secretary.
The motion was seconded by Councilman Reynolds and passed by a 7 - 0 vote .
Councilman Galinson stated that because he had legal and business interests
in the liquor industry he would disqualify himself from the hearing if so desired
by any party . No objections were noted by either the Council or by Mr . George
Faust , owner of Culbertson ' s , Inc . dba George Faust ' s Restaurant .
The City Attorney gave a summary of the situation and explained that the
meeting was called as a hearing on revocation or suspension of the off - sale
i liquor license of Culbertson ' s , Inc . dba George Faust ' s Restaurant , 5916
Excelsior Boulevard due to recent alleged violation of the intoxicating liquor
licensing ordinance involving minors .
After consultation between representatives of the City and the licensee , it
was stipulated and agreed that the factual basis of the hearing with respect
to the violation claimed by the City would be based upon the documentary
evidence to be presented by the City Attorney to the
City Council , consisting of the Notice of Hearing with roof of service
attached , subpoenas with p
p proof of service attached , certified copy of judg -
ment of the Hennepin County Municipal Court for hearing held in St . Louis
Park , a copy of the offense report of the Police Depar i a ertified copy of
the birth certificate of Stephen Vilipskicopy t
, and a co of he letter from the City
Manager to George Faust regarding the matter . All of these documents Fere
received in evidence by the Mayor on behalf of the Cit Council and declared
to be findings of fact . y
The second phase of the hearing having to do with the consideration of
— 326
Council Minutes , October 2 7 , 1969
mitigating circumstances and the imposition of disciplinary action , if any ,
Were found to be necessary was also stipulated and agreed to be presented
to the Council by the representatives of the various parties involved , reserving
the right to take evidence as to any aspects of the hearing which presented
serious questions of the fact .
The Council questioned Stephen Vilipski , age 180 who testified that he had
purchased liquor from Faust ' s Liquor Store on previous occasions with a
falsified driver ' s license but that on August 12 , 1969 , he purchased liquor
without showing proof of age at the store . Mr . Vilipski stated that he could
not subsequently identify which of the several clerks on duty at the time
made the sale .
The Council then questioned Officer Dennis Beltrand , the arresting officer .
Mr . Beltrand stated that while on regular patrol he observed Mr . Vilipski
Vi
entering Faust ' s Liquor Store and concluded that he may have been under age .
Mr . Beltrand testified that he followed Mr . Vilipski for several blocks and
apprehended him for speeding at which time he discovered the liquor in
Vilipski ' s car . Ivtr . Vilipski was not in possession of a driver ' s license at
the time of apprehension . Beltrand stated that his intention in delaying
apprehension was to trace the possible destination of Vilipski and the liquor ,
Detective Richard Morgan presented a statement that Iver . Vilipski had a
beard at the time of the incident which altered his appearance , but denied that
the beard affected the officer ' s judgment . Morgan also stated that the City
Attorney erred in his summary giving the time of occurrence as " late at
night " when it occurred at 1 : 00 p . m . Morgan testified that Vilipski was
not recognized by any of the clerks in the liquor store when he was returned
to the store and that the department received full cooperation from the
restaurant during the investigation .
Under questioning by the Council , Richard Hubbard , liquor store manager ,
testified that employees were required to ask for proof of age in questionable
cases and that such proof would be at least two identification sources such as
driver ' s license and selective service registration card . Mr . Hubbard stated
that it was very unusual for Vilipski to have purchased liquor with only one
card , Hubbard felt that two identification requirement is good procedurally
when enforced . Hubbard also stated that the Police Department has not
been called in cases of questionable age and that if a false identification is
Produced , the sale is refused . The false identification has been confiscated
under previous management , but the City Attorney questioned the legality of
g
such action ,
police tred information that his department has
Chief Clyde Sorensen volunteered
received calls from Faust ' s Restaurant relative to identification problems .
Geprge Fauststatement to the Council in which he expressed
presented a uilt derived therein ,
no doubt as to the occurrence of the incident and to the g
327
Council 1winutes , October 27 , 1969
but that his personal reputation as a restaurateur and community man were
ilty of criminal carelessness or intent .
at stake , and that he was not gu
After hearing all statements and questions , the Mayor declared a recess at
9 : 10 p . m . The meeting was reconvened at 9 : 55 p . m .
Councilman Graves moved no suspension of off - sale license . The motion
was seconded by Councilman Howard and passed by a 4 - 3 vote , Councilmen
Heltzer , Koch , and Mayor Thiel voting nay .
After further discussion a motion was made by Councilman Howard to have
the City Manager draw up an ' b.ffidavit of age " format for submission to the
Council Liquor Committee for study . The motion was seconded by Councilman
Reynolds and passed by a 7 - 0 vote .
Mayor Thiel declared the hearing closed at 10 : 10 p . m .
Leo rd J . Thiel , iayor
Attest :
Richard Schrad , Acting Secretary
328
MINUTES OF SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
ST . LOUIS PARK , MINNESOTA
October 27 , 1969
A Special meeting of the City Council was called to order by Mayor Thiel
at 10 : 10 p . m .
The following Councilmen were present :
Murray Galinson
Richard Graves
James Heltzer
Frank Howard
Richard Koch
Robert Reynolds
Leonard Thiel
Councilman Reynolds moved to direct the City Manager to initiate defense
proceedings in pending lawsuit , Twin City Disposal Service Co . , Inc . vs
the City of St . Louis Park , and to retain Mr . Ken Green of the firm of
O' Conner , Green , Thomas , Walters and Kelly to represent the City , and
to initiate counter - claim against Twin City Disposal Service . The motion
was seconded by Councilman Koch and carried unanimously .
Councilman Heltzer moved to authorize the City Manager to select the
parking consultant to perform selected parking studies for the City of
St . Louis Park . Motion was seconded by Councilman Howard and passed
by a 7 - 0 vote .
Councilman Heltzer moved that the City Council go on record as approving
Twin Cities Area Metropolitan Transit Commission acquisition of Twin City
Lines , Inc . The motion was seconded by Councilman Howard and passed by
a 6 - 1 vote , Mayor Thiel voting nay for lack of information on the issue .
Councilman Galinson moved to name the firm of Liebenberg , Kaplan ,
Glotte r
and Associates , Inc . , architectural firm , to perform the preliminary
he motion was
feasibility studies for the proposed municipal garage . ssion , Councilman
seconded b Councilman Reynolds . After some disc
Y
Howard moved to amend the motion to name also the firm Them tion was
Associates if the two firms are willing to work together*
seconded b Councilman Galinson . The amended motion failed or Thielto pass
a vote of 3 Y 4 , Councilmen Heltzer , Koch , Reynolds , and y
a e final motion was then passed by a vote of 6
voting nay . Th original
Councilman Howard voting nay *
seconded by Councilman Reynolds , the
On motion of Councilman Galinson • by a 7 yea vote *
meeting was adjourned at 10 : 50 p
Atte st : Thiel , Layor
Leo rd J .
Richard Schrad Actg . Secretary 329 - - -