HomeMy WebLinkAbout2026/10/07 - ADMIN - Minutes - Planning Commission - Study SessionOfficial Minutes
Planning commission
October 7, 2026
6:01 p.m.
Planning commission
Study Session
Members present: Jim Beneke, Christopher Caton, Mia Divecha, Matt Eckholm, John Flanagan,
Avi Nieves, Sarah Strain, Tom Weber
Members absent:
Staff present: Laura Chamberlain
Guests: Beth Elliott and Kristen Baldonado with Stantec
Item 1: 2050 Comprehensive Plan Update
Ms. Elliott explained Stantec's role includes engagement, particularly reaching residents who do
not normally participate. Commissioner Divecha asked about the consultants' frame of
reference, citing earlier parking discussions that benchmarked against much larger cities like
Portland and San Francisco. Ms. Elliott listed work in Minneapolis, Cottage Grove, Spring Lake
Park, Mounds View, Moorhead, Northfield, Owatonna, Texas, and Illinois.
Commissioners shared that they had been told that major changes must wait for the
comprehensive plan. They found it frustrating to arrive at the plan and be told that this was not
the time, particularly after the recent zoning code update, which largely codified existing
conditions. Ms. Elliott replied that the comprehensive plan would largely codify and bring up
into policy the work the city had done over the last decade, including the zoning updates and
the related comprehensive plan amendments. She said big ideas often emerge from public
engagement. She said her goal was to give the commission clear policy direction it could rely on
when making decisions and when receiving testimony.
Ms. Elliott and Ms. Baldonado reviewed the 10-year cycle, which runs from census data to
regional forecasts, the Imagine 2050 plan, and city system statements issued in fall 2025.
Forecasts cover population, households, and jobs, and the city must accommodate them. The
city has received its minimum requirements checklist, and consultants will send a link. Notable
requirements include:
Engagement of underrepresented populations.
Allowance of more than single-family housing in low-density land use categories.
Affordable housing at or below 50 percent of area median income.
Surface water, wastewater, and water supply plans, which require coordination with the
city's engineering consultants.
Climate as a required topic, with analysis of social vulnerabilities.
Neighboring jurisdictions and Metropolitan Council staff will review the plan in 2028, with
approval expected by the end of 2028. Noncompliance can make a city ineligible for funding.
Docusign Envelope ID: 05F8008D-F43F-8D1B-81B3-9745940DDCAE
Official minutes
Planning commission study session October 7, 2026
Page 2
2
Another commissioner cited the sewer dispute in North Oaks and the earlier lawsuit involving
Lake Elmo. Commissioner Caton asked whether St. Louis Park would later have to compensate
for other cities' shortfalls. He suggested raising the question with a Metropolitan Council
representative, and Ms. Elliott said it could be asked. She added St. Louis Park is living the
values the Metropolitan Council promotes.
The consultants said the plan would build on Vision 4.0 and the city council's five strategic
priorities rather than begin with a new visioning phase. Staff want it concise, visual,
implementation-focused, and supported by dashboards that are easy to maintain. It will also
include an interactive online story map. Ms. Elliott said that a 10-page plan is not possible given
the Metropolitan Council checklist, but that background material and checklist items can move
to appendices or be linked. Chair Strain asked for a balance that gives enough information to
explain why decisions or policy choices were made.
Stantec is partnering with Modern Day Me, which is finalizing an explanatory video. The first
engagement push will include on-the-ground outreach at festivals, bus stops, playgrounds, and
similar places, plus targeted online engagement. The winter newsletter is expected in early
December, and online engagement will stay open until the end of the year. A second push
focused on implementation is planned for late summer or early fall 2027, including two family-
friendly community-wide meetings. The consultants showed a sample street-interview video
from a Minneapolis project. In response to Commissioner Caton's question, Ms. Elliott
explained that interviewers asked a few non-invasive questions to track audiences reached,
responses are coded into themes by a data analyst, and results are shown publicly and
combined with online input. Ms. Elliott acknowledged the commissioners' priorities and
committed to incorporating them.
Stantec staff presented the following findings:
Metropolitan Council forecasts show growth of about 13 percent in population and
households and about 5 percent in employment between 2030 and 2050. This is roughly
3,400 added households, or about 170 per year, with shrinking household sizes
sustaining housing demand. Commissioner Caton said this was a large amount of
building.
The city attracts adults aged 25 to 34 and retains older residents. Commissioners
suggested that housing size, cost, and school quality may lead families to move outside
the city.
Single-person households are the largest household type. Commissioner Beneke noted
that older residents often cannot find affordable places to move.
The city is becoming more racially diverse, but language diversity is not keeping pace,
which has implications for engagement and services.
Poverty and social vulnerability are concentrated in the Aquila neighborhood. Ms. Elliott
said a citywide plan can still target policies geographically.
Housing is largely a choice between large apartment buildings and small single-family
homes, mostly under 1,500 square feet, with little middle-scale housing.
Homeownership is 58 percent overall with significant disparities by race and ethnicity
and high cost burden among lower-income households.
Docusign Envelope ID: 05F8008D-F43F-8D1B-81B3-9745940DDCAE
Official minutes
Planning commission study session October 7, 2026
3
Page 3
The full community profile is online on the project’s webpage and contains more detail for a
breakdown of units by owner and renter occupancy. Regarding condominium construction. Ms.
Elliott cited state legislation passed after the 2000s condo boom that increased developer
liability, and a commissioner cited FHA eligibility problems and rising HOA requirements. Ms.
Elliott said conversions of aging apartments are more likely than new construction, and that
Stantec's development economists could return to discuss these issues.
The city has a very high workforce participation rate and unemployment below county and
regional levels. About 40,000 people commute into the city to work, while only about 25,000
residents leave the city to work. Commissioners asked about work-from-home effects and the
effect of the coming light rail opening. Most industrial buildings predate 1990 but are well
leased. Of five aging commercial properties examined, three redeveloped into mixed use and
two were adaptively reused. Ms. Elliott said the future land use map could include layers such
as protected industrial categories and flexibility for accessory dwelling units, duplexes and
quads.
Commissioners reported that they were surprised by the number of commuters and by the
share of single-person households. A commissioner asked about the fiscal and economic
consequences of continued movement from industrial and commercial uses to housing with a
concern that there would be nowhere to work. Other comments from commissioners included:
Favoring industrial and commercial uses to compete with parking rather than with
housing.
Protecting small light-industrial pockets, such as small businesses near light rail stations.
Consider daily-needs businesses alongside destination businesses.
Emphasizing housing, supporting walkable neighborhood small-businesses, easing
barriers for startup businesses, and retention of existing businesses.
Commissioners asked that transportation (including bus transit) be included in the plan. Ms.
Elliott said the community profile has transportation, parks, and climate sections and that a bus
system change is open for public comment. Commissioners and consultants discussed the high
rents in new mixed-use buildings and possible tools: standard preapproved building plans, a
density bonus, traditional small shop-with-dwelling buildings and city financing conditions
through tax increment financing or the affordable housing trust fund.
Ms. Elliott suggested that, after the plan is adopted, the commission use a checklist of plan-
based discussion points to guide deliberation after public testimony.
Adjournment – 7:58 p.m.
______________________________ _______________________________
Laura Chamberlain, liaison Sarah Strain, chair member
These minutes were created with the assistance of a generative AI transcript service, then edited
and finalized by a city staff person.
Docusign Envelope ID: 05F8008D-F43F-8D1B-81B3-9745940DDCAE