Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2026/09/16 - ADMIN - Minutes - Planning Commission - Study SessionOfficial Minutes Planning commission September 16, 2026 6:01 p.m. Planning commission Study Session Members present: Jim Beneke, Christopher Caton, Mia Divecha, Matt Eckholm, John Flanagan, Sarah Strain, Tom Weber Members absent: Ari Nieves Staff present: Laura Chamberlain, Jennifer Monson Item 1: Parking discussion, case studies Ms. Chamberlain briefly outlined the policy resources included in the packet, which included materials from the Urban Land Institute, the Sustainable Development Code, the American Planning Association's Zoning Reform Toolkit, and a Bay Area regional government collaboration focused on parking policy. She outlined three goals: review the resources, discuss parking challenges and identify the commission’s priority outcomes. One commissioner observed that making comparisons between St. Louis Park and the cities featured in the case studies was difficult, given that most of those cities are significantly larger. Another suggested when viewed as part of the Minneapolis–St. Paul metro area, particularly as a first-ring suburb, St. Louis Park may share relevant characteristics with comparable urban neighborhoods. There may be specific pockets of the city that share characteristics with denser urban neighborhoods, suggesting that lessons from larger cities could be applied geographically rather than city-wide. Commissioners were struck by the cost of structured and underground parking (cited at about $35,000 per underground space). Several supported Seattle's "unbundling" policy, which separates parking costs from housing costs so that residents without cars do not subsidize those with them. A commissioner asked how unbundling might apply to businesses, and Ms. Chamberlain said this merited further review. Ms. Monson confirmed that recent zoning code updates had already removed parking requirements for the reuse of existing buildings zoned MU-1, MU-2, and MU-3. Ms. Chamberlain noted that these provisions apply to existing spaces, but that expansions still trigger current parking requirements. It was noted that eliminating minimums in the Walker Lake area was intended as a test case, to be evaluated after about a year before any expansion. Ms. Monson also noted that the city does maintain municipal parking lots that serve businesses, and that the costs of reconstructing those lots are typically assessed back to the property owners who use them. Docusign Envelope ID: 05F8008D-F43F-8D1B-81B3-9745940DDCAE Official minutes Planning commission study session September 16, 2026 Page 2 Commissioners generally supported reducing or eliminating parking minimums for commercial uses. Their reasons included more productive use of land, the net fiscal drain of low-density, moving away from parking-heavy development, stormwater and impervious surface concerns, walkability and safety, small business formation, and housing affordability. Commissioners also raised the need for supporting infrastructure beyond zoning, including transit, bicycle and pedestrian networks, and public education that street parking is a public asset. Ms. Chamberlain shared a series of practical concerns raised by city staff. She noted that the city is actively narrowing streets, which reduces on-street parking capacity. She acknowledged that the city's walking, biking, and transit networks remain incomplete, which complicates the assumption that residents can simply shift away from vehicle use. Other challenges included the cost of parking enforcement, snow removal logistics with increased on-street parking demand, and a growing number of resident petitions to re-establish resident-only parking on public streets. It was also noticed that high school students are using the city owned lot behind the Lake Street businesses. The conversation included the potential for more city-owned or municipally managed parking structures in key commercial areas, such as the Excelsior corridor. Ms. Chamberlain said strategic municipal parking districts, as recommended in earlier plans, would require a stronger policy foundation, ideally in the comprehensive plan. Ms. Monson noted that funding such districts is difficult because assessments are charged back to nearby businesses. Ms. Monson also said that if minimums were removed, businesses might expand into former parking areas rather than convert them to other uses. Commissioner raised the importance of ensuring that any reduction in parking does not disproportionately affect residents with disabilities or mobility challenges. Ms. Chamberlain responded by acknowledging the concern while noting that, statistically, households with disabled members are more likely to rely on transit and less likely to own vehicles. It was suggested there be a "yes and" approach that would improve accessibility through both ADA- compliant parking provisions and accessible pedestrian infrastructure, rather than using accessibility as a justification for maintaining excess parking. Commissioners' Priority Outcomes: Increased density and land use efficiency - Reduce the amount of land dedicated to surface parking, particularly in areas where that land could support housing, retail, or other productive uses. Housing affordability - The cost of structured parking is a significant contributor to housing costs. A safe, enjoyable, convenient and accessible walking environment - The parking policy should serve the goal of making the city more walkable, with an explicit emphasis on ensuring that accessibility for people with disabilities is maintained and enhanced, not diminished. Docusign Envelope ID: 05F8008D-F43F-8D1B-81B3-9745940DDCAE Official minutes Planning commission study session September 16, 2026 Page 3 Enabling more neighborhood-scale commercial uses - Create the conditions for neighborhood coffee shops, small restaurants, and other pedestrian-oriented businesses to locate in residential areas where they are currently unable to do so. Reducing impervious surface and supporting green infrastructure - Environmental value of reducing parking footprints, including benefits for stormwater management and tree canopy. Adaptability and reuse of existing structures - Ability to repurpose existing buildings and parking structures without triggering new parking requirements as a key priority. Due diligence on worst-case scenarios – Study potential negative outcomes before advancing policy changes, in order to be able to respond credibly to public concern and secure the necessary votes on the city council. Education and community engagement - Public perception often does not align with the realities of parking policy; any reform effort needs to include a robust community education component to build understanding and support. Fiscal responsibility and metrics - A measurable outcome, such as a reduction in vehicles per household, should be tracked to evaluate whether policy changes are achieving their intended effect. Alternatives to driving Ms. Chamberlain said staff would use the priorities list to plan next steps and planned to include the parking discussion into the upcoming comprehensive planning process. Adjournment – 7:42 p.m. ______________________________ _______________________________ Laura Chamberlain, liaison Sarah Strain, chair member These minutes were created with the assistance of a generative AI transcript service, then edited and finalized by a city staff person. Docusign Envelope ID: 05F8008D-F43F-8D1B-81B3-9745940DDCAE