Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2026/10/12 - ADMIN - Minutes - City Council - Study SessionOfficial minutes Study session St. Louis Park, Minnesota October 12, 2026 The meeting convened at 6:01 p.m. Council Members present: Jim Engelking, Sue Budd, Mayor Nadia Mohamed, Tim Brausen, Paul Baudhuin Council Members absent: Daniel Bashore, Yolanda Farris Staff present: city manager (Ms. Keller), community development director (Ms. Barton), deputy community development director (Mr. Walther), planning and economic development manager (Ms. Monson), finance director (Ms. Stephens) Guests: senior municipal advisors with Ehlers (Ms. Kvilvang, Mr. Aarsvold) Discussion items 1. Tax Increment Financing discussion Ms. Monson presented the Tax Increment Financing (TIF) dashboard on the city website, which staff updates annually. It lists every TIF district established since 1972 with approval dates, certification status, base value, current value, taxable value growth and units created. Ms. Monson cited the Elmwood district, established in 2017 and since decertified, which produced 70 units including affordable units. Citywide, TIF districts generated more than $1.5 billion in taxable value growth since 1973 from about $114 million invested. Staff will add final 2026 figures in early 2027. Council Member Engelking asked for the city's total taxable value for context. Ms. Monson committed to providing the figure. Council Member Brausen observed that the increment represents revenue the city would not have received without redevelopment. Council Member Budd noted every TIF project passed the “but-for” test. Ms. Monson said TIF has been used to advance St. Louis Park’s vision, goals, and the Comprehensive Plan including Excelsior and Grand redevelopment, climate action, and affordable housing goals. She said TIF has also been used to fund public amenities and contamination cleanup. The city directed more than $10 million in accumulated tax increment to the affordable housing trust fund. TIF also funded the Excelsior Boulevard streetscape, bridge improvements, Louisiana Avenue stormwater ponds, a signal at Quentin Avenue and public infrastructure for the Beltline Station Development. Excess increment funded building rehabilitation, the Wooddale Avenue bridge expansion, infrastructure improvements on 36th Street and Wooddale Avenue, city contributions to the Green Line light rail (LRT) extension, and a future signal at Parkglen Road and Beltline Boulevard. Council Member Budd asked where pooled increment outside the housing trust fund goes. Ms. Monson answered that it stays in each district for qualified redevelopment or affordable Docusign Envelope ID: E9492F11-A6A4-8B61-807A-AFBC34DA735B Study session minutes - 2 - October 12, 2026 housing costs. Ms. Barton explained that increment pooled for housing funds housing, while increment pooled for redevelopment funds development-related infrastructure. Ms. Kvilvang added that it can also fund blighted building demolition and contamination cleanup. Ms. Monson reported TIF districts produced affordable housing for 15% of units, 628,000 square feet of commercial space, more than 1.3 million square feet of office space, 200,000 square feet of industrial space and 488 hotel rooms. A Hennepin County value-per-acre analysis by Urban3 showed the city’s highest market value properties matched previously established TIF districts. In the Elmwood redevelopment case study, the TIF parcel reached $17.24 million in taxable value. The neighboring untouched parcel reached $1.9 million. Ms. Barton added that the Elmwood TIF district was established in 2017 and has already been decertified and the full taxable value is on the tax rolls. Ms. Monson described the pyramid of discretion. Financial assistance carries the council's highest discretion. Staff screens projects against city goals before presenting them. Ms. Kvilvang explained the two statutory “but-for” tests: whether the market value increase would occur without TIF, and whether the project would proceed in the reasonably foreseeable future without assistance. She also described the city's third test, a review of developer sources, uses and 15-year cash flows against market norms. In the Texa-Tonka example, the developer requested $3.3 million and received $2.6 million over 12 years. The award reflected $1.3 million in extraordinary costs plus $1.2 million for the affordability write-down. A look-back reviews qualified costs and stabilized operations at 95% occupancy. If a project is performing better than originally anticipated, the city will reduce the amount of financial assistance provided. If a project is underperforming, the city does not increase its contribution. Council Member Baudhuin asked about developer profit and executive compensation. Ms. Kvilvang answered that developer fees run 2 to 3% of total costs. Investors require market returns of roughly 10% cash on cash or 7.25 to 7.5% on cost. Texa-Tonka projected a 6% cash return. Ms. Barton added that staff rejects returns above market. Ms. Monson told the council to apply the TIF policy guardrails consistently. The council may not deny a policy-compliant project by imposing new restrictions. A policy change must come first. Council Member Budd cited prevailing wage as an example. Council Member Baudhuin asked whether too many similar projects justified a denial. Ms. Monson answered yes, as a portfolio consideration requiring no policy change. She urged the council to communicate concerns early. She cited the Mera project, where early council feedback led to a revised proposal with 20% affordable units at 50% area median income. Ms. Monson outlined four reports per project: initial request and recommended assistance, business terms, public hearing then final approvals. An example she provided was for the Creekline Flats development, where the council will hold a public hearing on Oct. 26, 2026. The hearing addresses only financial assistance. Mayor Mohamed asked how long the process typically takes between the initial report and final approval. Ms. Monson answered that it varies by project. She mentioned that low income housing tax credit projects typically have six months between tax credit awards and when Docusign Envelope ID: E9492F11-A6A4-8B61-807A-AFBC34DA735B Study session minutes - 3 - October 12, 2026 construction needs to occur, so the process moves fast. However, she noted that there are legal notice requirements pertaining to establishment of TIF districts, which require a 30- to 60-day agency review. Ms. Barton stressed that council members may voice reservations at any stage. They may change positions on new information. Councilmember Budd asked where other projects are in the process. Ms. Monson reported 2625 Louisiana did not act fast enough and its approvals have been rescinded. Staff will remove it from the next quarterly development report. Terasa is expected to open late 2027. Beltline B3 is anticipated to receive its certificate of occupancy Oct. 23, 2026. Council Member Baudhuin asked how staff examine developers. Ms. Barton answered that staff checks references, reviews past projects, contacts other jurisdictions, consults with Ehlers, and consults attorneys about pending allegations. Council Member Baudhuin asked how the TIF policy compares with other cities. Mr. Walther relayed the city attorney's view that St. Louis Park sets a high bar tied to public benefits. Council Member Budd credited the green building policy, the inclusionary housing policy and public art requirements. Council Member Engelking relayed a developer's comment that TIF roughly offset the city's added costs. Council Member Budd asked whether the public hearing addresses building appearance. Ms. Barton answered that it addresses financial assistance only. Planning Commission hearings address zoning. Council Member Baudhuin noted opposition to building height cannot influence the financing decision. Mayor Mohamed noted tension arises when a project meets policy the council dislikes. She asked what levers exist for developers requesting no funding. Ms. Barton answered that the council holds little discretion over zoning-compliant projects without variances. Mr. Walther mentioned that staff would need more concrete examples in order to respond with the appropriate tools to address concerns. 2. Tax Increment Financing management update Ms. Kvilvang reported the city created 32 TIF districts since 1972. Seventeen remain active: six housing, nine redevelopment, two renewal and renovation. Transformational districts drew the largest investment, followed by affordable housing then standard redevelopment at about $30 million. Active districts hold 5,600 housing units with 17% affordable. The 14 fully developed districts show about $1 billion in valuation growth, roughly 1,100% increase in value. Council Member Budd asked how that figure was calculated. Ms. Kvilvang answered that it compares base value at creation with 2026 market value. It excludes Terasa and Beltline Station 1 and 2 since they are not yet completed. Zarthan and Mill City must decertify at the end of 2026. Under special legislation adopted in 2021, the city may transfer unused increment to the affordable housing trust fund. Doing so frees the funds from TIF restrictions. Through 2025 the city transferred about $10 million. Staff recommended these actions: Docusign Envelope ID: E9492F11-A6A4-8B61-807A-AFBC34DA735B Study session minutes - 4 - October 12, 2026 ● Keep the Aquila district open through 2027 to transfer about $208,000. ● Make the 2026 affordable housing election for Bridgewater Bank to transfer about $590,000. ● Make the 2026 affordable housing election for Wooddale Station to transfer about $540,000. ● Transfer about $3.68 million in 2026, bringing the total to about $13.6 million. The deadline to make the elections is Dec. 31, 2026. Captured tax capacity fell from 11.7% in 2025 to 9.1% in 2026. It will fall to 8.3% in 2027 then drop further in 2028 when Park Commons and Highway 7 end. It will stay between 6.5 and 7% through 2031 absent new districts. At the 2026 city rate of 51%, Zarthan and Mill City free about $494,000. Park Commons frees about $1.5 million. Council Member Engelking asked whether the freed capacity brings tax relief. Ms. Kvilvang answered that rates fall if spending holds constant; added costs mute the effect. Council Member Brausen asked whether the 2027 budget includes the expirations. Ms. Stephens stated it did not. Staff used low estimates, leaving about $300,000 of room. Mr. Walther clarified that Park Commons sits in the Excelsior and Grand area; Ms. Kvilvang agreed. Ms. Kvilvang estimated decertifying Aquila in 2026 would cut $3.84 from the average homeowner's taxes. Bridgewater Bank would affect the average home by slightly over $4. Council Member Engelking asked why the impacts were not proportional to the dollar amounts. Mr. Walther noted that fiscal disparities send part of commercial tax base to the region. Ms. Barton noted the council reviews each district annually. Mayor Mohamed relayed Council Member Bashore's support for all recommendations. He leaned toward decertifying Aquila but would join the majority. Ms. Keller also relayed Council Member Farris's support for the recommendations. Council Member Brausen supported all recommendations. Council Member Budd called the recommendations sound investments benefiting taxpayers. Council Member Engelking supported the recommendations. Mayor Mohamed supported the recommendations. Staff confirmed consensus on all four policy questions. Staff will prepare EDA and council actions for formal votes. Written Reports 3. Welcoming, safe community system wrap-up Council Member Engelking praised the summary recap format for providing a clear close-out. 4. Boards and Commissions Advisory Communication form - Community Technology Advisory Commission Whitepaper: Artificial Intelligence Docusign Envelope ID: E9492F11-A6A4-8B61-807A-AFBC34DA735B Study session minutes - 5 - October 12, 2026 Council Member Budd called the research helpful. It consolidated sources she lacked capacity to gather. She valued the council recommendations. Council Member Brausen praised the white paper on artificial intelligence (AI). He asked about staff's reaction. Staff answered they supported the direction. The commission shared a draft with the communications and technology department; staff requested additions describing city efforts and appreciated the 2027 budget contributions. Council Member Brausen asked whether a cap on pay-as-you-go AI usage costs existed. Staff answered they would check. Staff asked the council to affirm AI protections at the policy level. Staff will return with operational proposals through the budget plus policy processes. Council Member Budd asked whether a study session request was needed. Staff answered that council affirmation suffices. Council Member Brausen asked about a follow-up in four to six months. Staff agreed to prepare a formal update through the good governance system. Council Member Engelking serves as ambassador to the commission. He praised the writing quality, peer city examples, readiness guidance, governance guardrails and risk warnings. He estimated a consultant would charge five figures for comparable work. Council Member Brausen agreed the paper was outstanding. Another council member commended the commission's emphasis on public feedback, transparency and coordination with the League of Minnesota Cities. The meeting adjourned at 7:24 p.m. ______________________________________ ______________________________________ Melissa Kennedy, city clerk Nadia Mohamed, mayor These minutes were created with the assistance of a generative AI transcript service, then edited and finalized by a city staff person. Docusign Envelope ID: E9492F11-A6A4-8B61-807A-AFBC34DA735B